We showcase a newly developed mapping approach that facilitates the selection of protected areas suitable for the conservation of terrestrial biodiversity in perpetuity. Areas are assessed based on their importance for biodiversity, as well as intactness, size and projected resilience to climate change. Additionally, we incorporate assessments of relationships among governments, NGOs and communities at the site as relevant to long term management and monitoring. Using a multi criteria analysis, we then create a database of sites comprising ideal candidates for an integrative conservation approach which combines inputs of scientists, conservationists, governments, funders and local stakeholders. Identifying suitable sites not solely based on their ecological value, but also considering their potential for future persistence based on intactness, climatic resilience and capacity for efficient management is vital to the permanent protection of the world’s rapidly decreasing biodiversity.